Good morning class Now, hands up everyone who knows what Soylent Green is made of Ah, that s very good I m glad to see you read your assignment.I m sorry, we re not quite finished yet What is the book s original title No, of course it isn t a trick question You should have read it a little carefully Before we had dystopian novels being pushed out like crazy in the 2000 s, Make Room, Make Roomcame out in 1966 and brought up a bleak and disturbingly believable dystopian future world, one filled with extreme overpopulation, pollution and madness It s still just as chilling today, in fact the 21st century has made it even believable than it used to be, making for a frightening but very intriguing book.If you re a fan of the 1970 s film Soylent Green, well, Make Room, Make Roomwas the basis for that film And the film s memorable scene with the detective screaming out SOYLENT GREEN IS PEOPLE IT S MADE OUTTA PEOPLE, WE GOTTA STOP EM SOMEHOW isn t in the book So if you re reading Make Room, Make Room expecting a movie novel, you won t find that but you still won t be disappointed Make Room, Make Room is an amazing novel with a nostalgic feel but a timeless message. Escritor Prol Fico, Harru Harrison Conquistou Um Vasto P Blico, Cativando Pela Sua Imagina O E Pelo Empenho Que P E Nos Seus Livros A Caminho De Bolso Revelou O Ao Leitor Portugu S Com Universo Cativo N , Que, Como Disse Um Cr Tico, Se L Com Redobrado Interesse Medida Que Se Sucedem As P Ginas Apresentamos Agora Este Fascinante Livro, Vencedor Do Pr Mio N Bula, Cujo T Tulo Portugu S Beira Do Fim Foi Levado Ao Cinema Por Richard Fleischer E Muitos Leitores Se Lembrar O Do Filme E De Outros Cuja Atmosfera Este Livro Antecipa Vincadamente Narrado Num Ritmo Impar Vel, Levanta Tamb M Algumas Quest Es Cruciais E Caso Para Perguntar Se O Leitor Concordar Com O Velho Solomon Kahn Acha De Facto Que Ele Tem Raz O Toda A Raz O Certo Que Merece A Nossa Simpatia, Mas Tem Raz O Tal Qual N O Perca Este Livro If you re into stuff like this, you can read the full review.Malthus Make Room Make Room by Harry Harrison Original Review, 1980 08 19 Pournelle s virulently infectious optimism is severely misplaced Other people have already pointed out that his strategy involves the probable abandonment of Earth and the bulk of its population what the hell, they re just gooks anyway I ll just add that even RAH 2018 EDIT Heinlein saw this approx 30 years ago in FARMER IN THE SKY a character acknowledges that even with the huge ships in use they can t possibly take off than a fraction of the population increase or absorb it in a colonial world they re simply hoping to have some racial survival after Earth is ruined. First thing, Forget about the movie Soylent Green which was based on Harry Harrison s novel about overpopulation, Make Room Make Room There is no Charleston Heston screaming , Soylent Green is people and nothing about cannibalism What we have instead is a very effective and disquieting look at a future where overpopulation is rampant and food and water sources are depleting While he centers his story around a New York detective and a accidental murder, Harrison is interested in depicting his character s personal responsse to their environment Sol beautifully played by Edward G Robinson in the movie and the best thing about the film is most memorable with his ability to remember the past and his examination of where they went wrong His soliloquy on birth control still rings true today Yet all the novel s protagonists are nicely developed Considering the topic, this is actually a fairly subtle novel and one of the best novels by veteran Sci fi writer Harrison Highly recommended with a strong four stars. So mankind gobbled in a century all the world s resources that had taken millions of years to store up, and no one on the top gave a damn or listened to all the voices that were trying to warn them, they just let us overproduce and overconsume until now the oil is gone, the topsoil depleted and washed away, the trees chopped down, the animals extinct, the earth poisoned, and all we have to show for this is seven billion people fighting over the scraps that are left, living a miserable existence and still breeding without control So I say the time has come to stand up and be counted Is overpopulation still a thing When was the last time you heard it discussed I don t know the answer to that, there are opposing views on whether overpopulation still poses a significant threat to all of humanity or, since population growth has stabilized in many countries, some demographic analysts are saying that it is no longer a serious matter Nowadays climate change is generally viewed as a pressing issue.In the 60s overpopulation was perceived as a major threat and it is one of the dystopian tropes often used by sci fi authors Several overpopulation sci fi novels have become classics of the genre, John Brunner s Stand on Zanzibar, The Sheep Look Up by the same author, and Robert Silverberg s The World Inside spring to mind However, for me, the one emblematic sci fi book on this subject is Harry Harrison s Make Room Make RoomMake Room Make Roomwas first published in 1966, it is set in the then future of 1999, starting in August and ends shortly after midnight of January 1st, 2000 In this version of 1999, the global population is seven billion, food, water, electricity and living accommodations are scarce In New York, where the novel is set, millions of people are living on the streets, public transportation is no longer in operation, and all basic necessities are strictly rationed Wheat crackers have become a staple food, and meat is mostly only available in an artificial form called soylent meat , produced from soya beans.But how do you tell a story about overpopulation The concept does not seem to lend itself to conventional plotting Harrison does this by focusing on just a few protagonists rather than writing an epic but fragmented novel about a large cast of characters Detective Andy Rusch is the main character of this book, he shares a cramped little apartment with Sol, a retired engineer Andy is assigned to investigate a murder of an important businessman called Michael O Brien who is, in reality, a gangster with political connections O Brien lives in a walled off luxury apartment with access to unlimited electricity and water supply, they even have air conditioning This is where Andy meets Shirl Greene, O Brien s girlfriend who was living with the murder victim and now has to move out The two predictably form a relationship To the readers the identity of the killer is not a mystery it is a destitute teenager who attempted to burgle the apartment, and was caught in the act by O Brien and accidentally killed him in self defense.The first half of the book is so focused on the murder investigation that I did wonder how this is a novel about overpopulation, let alone a sci fi novel However, the dystopia is always there in the background, in the state of Andy s apartment, the people lying on the street that he has to step over to get into his home, his roommate powering their refrigerator by hooking it to a bicycle and cycling like mad In the second half of the book, the murder investigation fades into the background and an accident causes sea water to seep into the water supply which is quickly shut down Water become even strictly rationed and is only available from water stations which has to be carried home in bottles and buckets Children are beginning to contract kwashiorkor, a form of severe protein energy malnutrition hitherto nonexistent in the US Living condition deteriorates throughout the narrative and a massive city wide riot seems imminent Make Room Make Roompaints a grim and depressing picture of an overpopulated New York, it frighteningly depicts the dehumanizing effect of overpopulation The way of life we take for granted is not sustainable under such conditions, even the simple human interrelationships between family members and friends are corroded by the constant suffering and hardship Make Room Make Roomis not a fun read as such, it is too harrowing for that, but it is a good, thought provoking read It is quite well written, with a clear straightforward prose, the characters are well developed and sympathetic The fact that the actual year 1999 was nothing like this is not a reason to dismiss this cautionary tale out of hand For all we know, Harrison has only overestimated the timing but the catastrophe he depicts here is still possible.Notes The film adaptation of Make Room Make Roomis much better known than the book It is a 1973 movie called Soylent Green It departs from the source material in many details especially the titular foodstuff , but is true to the book s spirit Q Is overpopulation still a problem A Yes No Maybe Harry Harrison is one of the popular sci fi authors during the 60s through to the 80s, his popularity declined a bit from the 90s onward Sadly he passed away in 2012 Make Room Make Roomis atypical of his output He tended to write fast paced, lighthearted sci fi adventures, like his signature series The Stainless Steel Rat, my personal favorite of his book is West of Eden.Quotes The millennium is here, now, upon us a populous world of souls awaiting His call This is the true millennium False prophets said it was the year one thousand, but there are people here in this single city than there were in the entire world at that time Now is the hour, we can see it nearing, we can read the signs The world can hold no , it will crack asunder under the weight of the masses of people We can go without washing for a while, it won t kill us, and when the water is connected up again we can all have a good scrub It s something to look forward to Face it, this city is through What they need here is animal trainers, not policemen This whole country is one big farm and one big appetite There s just as many people down South as there is up North and, since there s no public transportation, anyone who tried to walk to the land of sunshine would starve to death long before he got there People stay put because the country is organized to take care of them where they are New York City trembled on the brink of disaster Every locked warehouse was a nucleus of dissent, surrounded by crowds who were hungry and afraid and searching for someone to blame Their anger incited them to riot, and the food riots turned to water riots and then to looting, wherever this was possible. Of course I remember the movie Soylent Green I saw it at the drive in gazillions of years ago, and many times since But let me tell you, as dramatic as the movie is, with Charlton Heston as main character Andy Rusch giving the infamous scream of view spoiler Soylent Green is PEOPLE hide spoiler Oddly enough, I kinda expected something hokey before I read this, but instead, I just got a dystopian nightmare of overpopulation.This isn t unexpected or a bad thing After all, I ve seen Soylent Green and felt the huge impact of the scene where the old man Saul mouths the BIG SECRET through the plane of glass I remember the riots, the pressure, the senseless violence, and the massive levels of injustice AND stupidity that brought us to this state.And yet, after reading this novel, that sense is visceral, realistic, and a lot less sensational Yes, there s massive injustice Just look at the Squatter law that gives priority to squalid massive families regardless of any consideration, or the way no detective is able to do his job because life is already worthless.For 66, this nightmare world that has used up all resources by 1999 and has ignored or actively fought all birth control or warnings, has resorted to sticking its head in the sand Sound familiar Well, fortunately, our modern world is getting well adjusted to living with less and less and some technologies are letting us live with a bit less squalor than predicted in this novel and a New York City of 35 million in the novel is pretty damn close to what some cities are reaching now, true, but the quality of life is NOT as bad as predicted in Harrison s novel.Of course, in some ways, the violence, the poverty, and the cultural clamp downs are WORSE in our world It s odd to see our 7.7 billion people displayed against the novel s measly 7.0 billion And yet it s interesting because most of the world is a dustbowl and the only place to safely live on the dole is the big cities, so everyone migrates there.I m just saying this is a really fascinating world building exercise I love books that predict or fail to predict in really big ways Does anyone want any meat flakes It s just snails right Yum, yum. Color me happy and than a little surprised to be decorating this review with as many stars as I am because I went into this novel with pretty subdued expectations I would say expectations on par with those I hold for the latest cinematic embarassment by Mr Dickoless Cage I know that s not very nice, but I will never, never forgive that talent free ass bozo for effectively castrating Ghost Rider in front of the general public, despite being a self described fanboy of the character The guy should be tied up in a Pulp Fiction style basement and JAMhandled by the gimp WOW, okayI am way off on a tangent here aren t I let s get back to the book.Where was I Oh yeah.So leaving aside shitty actors with no ability, this is an excellent novel and a very welcome surprise Written in 1966 but taking place in 1999 the story posits a world reaping the results of massive over population and the depletion of natural resources.which of course we know could NEVER really happen and is just one of those wacky SF ideas these weirdo writers come up with Hmm Anyway, while loosely framed as a mystery involving a hard boiled detective investigating a murder, this plot device is really just a means by which the author explores the future society of New York City population 35 Million, as opposed to the just under 10 Million of present day 2011.What really grabbed me by the fruits about the story is the terrific sense of place the author establishes through random, but well chosen, details about life in this future New York Harrison is able to seamlessly weave into the narrative the most fascinating snapshots of the world without resorting to big, drawn out expositional paragraphs I was very impressed by his control over his story This novel is a lesson in exceptional world building.We learn significant background details such as information involving food riots, foodstuffs made from plankton, soy bean and lentil steaks, ever increasing prices of commodities, water shortages, debates about birth control, and that all of the characters suffer from physical ailments resultng from mal nutrition or disease The author provides this well fleshed, intricate picture of the world without dropping major dumps of info that would clog up the natural flow of the story Well done, sir Well done indeed In addition to the exceptionally delivered background info, the characters are very much three dimensional and act pursuant to complex and subtle motivations This kind of high level development is unusual for this kind of short 60 s science fiction novel Again the author exceeed expectations and his ability to do that consistently is worthy of serious kudos To sum up, this is a terriific story While not up to the all time great status of a book like Stand on Zanzibar which is my standard for this kind of science fiction story , this is certainly an outstanding story and among the best of its type that I have read.4.5 to 5.0 stars HIGHEST POSSIBLE RECOMMENDATION Here is a 1966 novel about 1999 which is good, honest, miserable fun The main guy who is a cop gets to be really happy for about two pages and after that it s back to worrying about absolutely everything It s New York City and the population has skyrocketed to 35 million The whole damn country has kind of collapsed There are no private cars Tobacco is a thing of the past There are meateasies This is because you can get your meat but you have to know where But pretty much everything is now scarce because Americans in the 30 years between 1966 and 1999 ate everything and used up everything whilst all having ten kids who then had another ten kids each, it seems.You wouldn t want to live in this version of New York City You wouldn t want to even visit it for ten minutes.CHUNK This humble word is Harry Harrison s absolute favourite No idea why If you had a shot of vodka each time he uses the word CHUNK you d be dead of severe alcoholic poisoning before page 90 My own favourite word is GALLIMAUFRY but you don t see me shoehorning it into every review willynilly Willynilly is another of my favourite words.BILLY NO MATES A THEORYMy latest literary insight is that in most novels, especially thrillerish ones, the protagonist has no friends Check the last three novels you read I think this is because it would make the story too complicated and annoying for the author would get in the way of the action Make Room Make Rooms two main characters begin with one sort of friend for him and none for her Novelists, this is very unrealistic People have friends Even I have friends Our hero s friend is nothing than a SOCK PUPPET so that Harry Harrison can explain his ideas of how overpopulation killed the USA and will kill the whole human race unless we embrace birth control The message of this novel couldn t be clearer if Harry Harrison personally came round to your house and nailed it to your forehead With another copy to be cellotaped to your bedroom mirror.HARRY ADMITS I GOT IT WRONGIn a one page afterword written in 2008 at the age of 83 HH says How right were my predictions Pretty bad in most of the general details but then he does say there s too many damn people and the developed world is soaking up all the planet s resources Which we know He predicted the population of NYC would increase from 8 million in 1966 to 35 million in 1999 which is RIDICULOUS But there is now a city Chongqing which Wiki tells me has reached 30 million And others aren t far behind Shanghai, 24m, Delhi, 21m The biggest population growth is in the developing world, and this tells us that HH didn t understand the part which says that there is a correlation between affluence and family size So the families of western people shrank over the 20th century I can see this in my own family grandparents generation 9 or 10 children parents generation two or three my own generation one or two or NONE I LIKED IT Even though it s a bit of a miseryfest, it zips along and HH has a real relish for all the horrible details.A CHUNKy three stars from me.
The Stainless Steel Rat and the novel
- Livro de bolso
- 198 pages
- Make Room! Make Room!
- Harry Harrison
- 07 February 2019 Harry Harrison